Memphis vs Nashville: Two Tennessee Cities on the Same Yardstick
Between April 2020 and July 2025, Memphis lost about 3.0% of its population while Nashville-Davidson grew 4.6%, and the median owner-occupied home in Nashville is valued at more than twice the Memphis median, according to Census Bureau QuickFacts. Those two facts frame most Memphis vs Nashville decisions: one city offers far lower housing costs, the other a larger and faster-growing job market. Which matters more depends on where your income comes from, and the details below can tip the answer either way.
The two cities on one table
| Measure (Census, Comptroller) | Memphis | Nashville-Davidson |
|---|---|---|
| Population estimate, July 2025 | 609,647 | 721,074 |
| Change since April 2020 | -3.0% | +4.6% |
| Median owner-occupied home value | $169,000 | $413,600 |
| Median monthly owner cost, with mortgage | $1,420 | $1,898 |
| Median gross rent | $1,181 | $1,586 |
| Mean commute to work (minutes) | 21.1 | 24.7 |
| Median household income | $51,736 | $77,371 |
| 2025 property tax rate per $100 assessed | 5.27081 (city plus Shelby County) | 2.782 (Davidson countywide) |
Census figures other than population are survey data from 2020 to 2024, and the Nashville column covers the consolidated Metro government’s “balance,” which leaves out a few small cities inside Davidson County. Both columns describe whole cities, so the spread inside each one is wide.
Jobs and pay
The metro economies differ in size and shape. In August 2026, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a preliminary civilian labor force of about 1.19 million in the Nashville metro area, with unemployment at 3.1%, compared with about 627,000 in the Memphis metro area, where unemployment stood at 4.6%.
Memphis is a freight hub: transportation and material moving jobs made up 17.1% of employment there in May 2025, roughly double the national share, per BLS occupational data for Memphis. The same release puts the Memphis area’s average hourly wage at $28.96, against $31.92 for the Nashville area and a national average of $33.54. Averages hide wide ranges by occupation, so compare offers in your own field.
Housing, and a property tax twist
Memphis homes carry a much higher tax rate and a much lower price. Run both through the Comptroller’s formula, where residential property is assessed at 25% of appraised value, per its bill calculation guide:
- At each city’s median value: a $169,000 Memphis home yields about $2,227 a year, and a $413,600 Nashville home about $2,877.
- At the same $300,000 value: using the 2025 rates, about $3,953 in Memphis against $2,087 in Davidson County.
Shelby and Davidson counties both show an appraisal ratio of 1.0000 in the Comptroller’s 2025 Tax Aggregate Report, which means appraisals in both track the market closely, so this is a fair comparison. The takeaway: if you plan to buy a larger or pricier home, the Memphis rate weighs more heavily, and the savings on price shrink as the house gets bigger. Some suburban cities in Shelby County carry lower combined rates than Memphis itself, which is one reason buyers often compare across city limits.
Reading the safety numbers carefully
Asking whether Nashville or Memphis is safer usually leads to two citywide rates. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation’s Crime in Tennessee 2025 report lists 14,771.3 Group A offenses per 100,000 residents for the Memphis Police Department and 9,851.8 for Nashville’s Metro police. Group A covers far more than violent crime, including drug violations, fraud and vandalism, and in both cities reported incidents concentrate in some areas while many residential neighborhoods record few.
That makes the citywide gap a weak guide to any specific street. Compare the neighborhoods on your shortlist using the same offense types, the same years and the same source, and check which agency patrols each address. This explainer on why crime maps for one city can disagree covers the methods behind the differences, and this breakdown of what goes into a neighborhood crime score shows what finer-grained data captures.
Want both cities scored on your terms? Line up Memphis and Nashville neighborhoods side by side on SettleSavvy’s free map, and see a 0 to 100 score for every neighborhood, weighted by what you said counts most.
Getting around, and getting between them
Both cities are largely car-dependent. Each runs a public bus system, and Nashville adds weekday commuter rail on one eastern corridor. The Census commute averages are close, with Memphis a few minutes shorter, though a home farther out in either metro will change that quickly.
The Memphis metro also crosses state lines: BLS defines it to include counties in Tennessee, Mississippi and Arkansas. A home on the other side of the line can change your state income tax, vehicle registration and school district, so check the rules before comparing it with a Tennessee address. Interstate 40 connects the two cities, but the drive takes several hours, so choosing one turns family in the other into a planned trip.
Which city suits which situation
Your income is portable. A remote worker or retiree keeps the same paycheck in either place, so the lower Memphis housing costs go straight to the bottom line. Compare total monthly cost, including the higher tax rate and insurance, for the type of home you want.
Your career is tied to a local market. Nashville’s larger labor force and higher average wage carry weight unless your field is logistics or another sector concentrated in Memphis. Search openings in your occupation in both metros before deciding.
You want more space for the money. In both cities, more space usually means more distance. Decide in advance how many extra minutes each way you will trade for another bedroom.
If you are still weighing other metros entirely, this step-by-step relocation method built on data can help you narrow the field first.
Testing the choice before you sign
Visit both cities with the same checklist: drive the likely commute on a weekday, run normal errands, walk the blocks you might live on and return after dark. Shortlist two or three neighborhoods per city. For Nashville, this guide to choosing among Nashville neighborhoods as a buyer shows how to narrow by priority. Then remember that the gap between neighborhoods inside one city often exceeds the gap between the two citywide averages, which is the core argument for using neighborhood data over city data.
When both shortlists are ready, a Savvy Consultant can compare them with you at no cost, covering commute, tax and the household needs that weigh most for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Memphis cheaper to live in than Nashville?
On housing, usually yes. Census data shows Memphis with a median home value of $169,000 against $413,600 in Nashville-Davidson, and a median rent about $400 a month lower. The Memphis property tax rate is nearly double Davidson’s, though, so compare full monthly costs for the specific homes you would consider.
Which city pays more, Memphis or Nashville?
BLS data puts the Nashville area’s average hourly wage at $31.92 and the Memphis area’s at $28.96, both below the national average. Pay varies far more by occupation than by city, so compare offers for your own role and set them against housing costs in the neighborhoods you would pick.
Is Memphis or Nashville bigger?
Nashville-Davidson’s population estimate of 721,074 tops Memphis at 609,647, and the Nashville metro’s labor force is roughly twice the Memphis metro’s. Population figures shift with the boundary a source uses, so confirm two numbers describe the same kind of area before comparing them.
Can I live in Mississippi or Arkansas and work in Memphis?
Yes. The federal definition of the Memphis metro area includes counties in both states. Crossing the line affects more than taxes: car insurance rates, which state’s public universities offer in-state tuition, and where you vote all follow your home address, so price those differences in alongside the commute.
How long is the drive between Memphis and Nashville?
Several hours each way along Interstate 40, depending on traffic and where in each metro you start. That distance means living in one city and working in the other is not practical as a daily commute, and family visits become weekend trips.